This matter-of-fact item appeared in the short-lived Semi-Weekly Independent of Plymouth on April 4, 1896.

Click on the image to display a larger version.

train holdup - 1896
Semi-Weekly Independent – April 4, 1896

The story made it all the way to San Francisco, where it ran more briefly but with a bit of added detail.

train holdup - 1896 - SF
San Francisco Call – April 2, 1896